5 Haunting Tales of True Crime in Los Angeles

October 17, 2016 by Guest Contributor

The following is a guest post by James T. Bartlett whose latest book, Gourmet Ghosts 2, looks at some of the lesser-known murders and weirdness (and ghosts) that took place in bars, restaurants and hotels in the City of Angels – places you can visit today!

* * * * * * *


America’s obsession with the murder and mystery of yesteryear has reached an all-time high. O.J. and JonBenét have come back to haunt us. Netflix is bursting with true crime documentaries. And that’s to say nothing of the “ripped from the headlines” shows we all chomp on like hungry zombies locked in a graveyard.

During my research for Gourmet Ghosts 2 I’ve had the unique opportunity to delve deeper still into the dark underbelly of our very own Los Angeles. What I’ve uncovered are countless tales of death and deception that titillate nearly as much as they confound.

And, if you’d allow me, I’d like to share just a few of my favorites below.

Albert Goldberg suicide at the Stowell Hotel

Love leads to tragedy at The Stowell Hotel in 1945. Photo via Los Angeles Public Library

1. The Thelma & Louise of The Fine Arts Building

September, 1967. The Fine Arts building is the scene of a theft by secretaries Terry Frank and Annalie Mohn. The pair stole thousands of dollars of bank securities from the company they worked for then made a Thelma & Louise/Psycho-style run for it across the country.

Fine Arts Building Los Angeles

The Fine Arts Building in Downtown Los Angeles. Photo by James T. Bartlett

Terry and Annalie hopped a ‘hound to Miami, where Terry’s estranged husband lived, but their high hopes for days of beach living would be soon come to an end.

Mixed up with a bad crowd (a gang that included thief Jack “Murf the Surf” Murphy), Terry and Annalie were found clad in their swimming suits and jewelry in an isolated waterway – and with blocks of concrete tied around their necks. They’d made it to Hollywood – but Hollywood, Florida.

2. Deadly Pills and The Plaza

The year was 1954, and Diane Wells was in town under a cloud.  She and her jazz drummer lover Johnny Warren were on the hook for the murder of Diane’s husband Cecil back in Fairbanks.

She was staying at the Drake Hotel – now the Scientology Welcome Center – and friends were worried about her; they’d already found pills in her handbag. The trial was coming, and it had everything, including an inter-racial affair and rumors of an abortion. That was red-hot stuff for the time.

Diane couldn’t handle it. She left the Drake, walked along Hollywood Blvd and turned onto Vine, taking a room at the Hollywood Plaza under a different name.

Hollywood Plaza Hotel. Photo by James T. Bartlett

Hollywood Plaza Hotel. Photo by James T. Bartlett

Later that night she swallowed a deadly dose of pills – and, of course, soon after that the case against her was dropped. You can share in that bittersweet memory at the Plaza – there’s a Chocolate Bar Pastry Café on street level – but back on the Boulevard there’s a suicide pact that requires your attention. It also began at the Drake, which was then called its original name, The Christie.

3. A Chorus Girl’s Chloroform

The year was 1924, and director Lew Mason turned on his gas taps, his suicide note reading:
“It’s too much, too fast.” But what was it? Turned out it was probably his affair with chorus girl Cecil Warner, who, on hearing the news, swallowed a bottle of chloroform – even though Mason wasn’t dead, just in the hospital. Her sad note?

“It all seems so futile to me…. not worth the reward.”

4. The Real American Horror Story Hotel

The Cecil Hotel was renamed Stay on Main some years ago, but signage indicating the old moniker remains to this day. Of course there’s more than just signs that make The Cecil a name that sticks.


While it’s true – but creepy – to think that all hotels have suffered a case or three of suicide over the years, the archives show that the Cecil has an extraordinary catalog of violence and death.

Hotel Cecil

The Hotel Cecil in 2005 before it was rebranded to Stay on Main. Photo by Jim Winstead via flickr cc

Serial killers, a sniper, an arsonist, a baby killer – they’ve all stayed there. And that’s to say nothing of many suicides, or the viral sensation that was the puzzling death of Elisa Lam, whose naked body was found in the water tank just a few years ago.

Talk about a real American Horror Story Hotel.

5. The Hoax Drowning

In June 1928 a jewelry thief named Ferdinand Albor was arrested. Ho hum.

Spooling ahead a few days in the newspaper archives though, there was a story about K.L. Baumgartner, who had returned from the dead – his clothes had been left on a beach in Venice, California, and it had been assumed he committed suicide.

Headline from the L.A. Examiner, July 24, 1928.

A headline from the L.A. Examiner, July 24, 1928.

But he hadn’t. He’d changed his name and occupation (he used to run a downtown restaurant; one I couldn’t pinpoint), and, yes, he was “Ferdinand Albor.”

He blamed a head injury for his four year scam, but since his wife had remarried, she now needed to obtain an annulment and then re-marry her new husband (a process that would take at least a year). Bizarrely, this meant that meant the estranged pair had to have an awkward meeting at the County Jail.

The L.A. Times, in a master of understatement, said it was a “strange reunion.”


gourmet-ghosts-2-coverGourmet Ghosts 2 is now available for purchase on Amazon ($19.95) and via select Los Angeles retailers. Author James T. Bartlett will be in conversation at The Last Bookstore on Oct. 28 at 7 p.m. Find out more about the author at gourmetghosts.com or follow him on Twitter @gourmetghosts.